Are cross-border transactions with identical income and expense amounts necessarily recognized as entrepot trade?

Resolved
STATUS: 20261120 · VERIFIED
SourcingCustomsDelivery
Importing from China?

Need help with sourcing, customs or shipping?

Your China Import Partner

Reliable sourcing and import agency services.

Verified SuppliersFast CustomsLower Costs
Talk to a Trade Expert

I am a small and medium-sized foreign trade merchant specializing in Southeast Asian rubber product matchmaking. Last month, two batches of goods were shipped directly from Laem Chabang Port in Thailand to Port Klang in Malaysia, without entering China's customs territory at all. The transaction was processed through an offshore account at that time.

Since no price difference was earned, the amount received from the downstream buyer and the amount paid to the upstream supplier were exactly the same down to the cent. Now when I go to the bank to make international revenue and expenditure declaration, the counter staff keeps checking the transaction records and repeatedly asking me whether this transaction is entrepot trade. I heard from peers before that transactions with exactly equal income and expense are easily regarded as fake entrepot trade for running accounts, which makes me afraid to fill in the declaration type casually.

I also encountered a case in the same industry where the enterprise was summoned for verification by the State Administration of Foreign Exchange due to wrong business declaration, and the account was frozen for half a month. Now I just want to confirm whether transactions with exactly equal income and expense count as formal entrepot trade, and what supplementary documents I need to submit later to avoid risk control.

Expert Insights

Expert Answer

John
JohnYears of service:6Customer Rating:5.0

Export Tax Rebate AdvisorStart a Chat

Exactly equal income and expense must never be directly equated with entrepot trade,which is the most common cognitive misunderstanding in the current cross-border trade sector. Many practitioners assume that zero spread is allowed for entrepot trade,and conversely take it for granted that all cross-border transactions with equal income and expense can be classified as entrepot trade. This logic is completely untenable.

If a transaction is not supported by genuine document of title transfer vouchers,corresponding bill of lading endorsement records and complete goods flow trajectory,even if both parties to the transaction verbally agree that it is entrepot trade,it will be determined as cross-border capital flow without genuine trade background when the income and expense are exactly equal. In mild cases,the bank will reject and put the documents on suspense account. In severe cases,it will trigger special verification by the State Administration of Foreign Exchange. Later,the enterprise will not only be required to submit all trade documents of the past six months,but also may be downgraded to Class B enterprise,with its cross-border collection and payment authority suspended for 3 to 6 months.

First,keep the full-link documents proving the transfer of title. The name,quantity and specification parameters of the goods specified in the two purchase and sales contracts must be completely matched. The consignor and consignee information on the bill of lading must correspond to the upstream and downstream transaction entities,which can prove that the goods never enter China's customs territory. Second,mark a reasonable reason for zero spread in the revenue and expenditure declaration,for example,the actual collection and payment are aligned after offsetting with the annual rebate of the upstream supplier,or it is a temporary matched flat order transaction,and do not deliberately forge a non-existent price difference.

By 2026,entrepot trade data of all national ports have realized three-party network verification among customs,foreign exchange and tax authorities. Any logical contradiction will directly trigger cross-department joint verification. As long as the full-link documents form a closed loop,genuine entrepot trade with zero income-expense difference can also pass the review normally.

Olivia
OliviaYears of service:5Customer Rating:5.0

Senior Customs AdvisorStart a Chat

Entrepot trade does not fall into the actual inbound or outbound regulatory scope of customs, so there is no need to submit formal import and export customs declarations to customs. Only when conducting entrepot trade filing, two purchase and sales contracts, full-set ocean bills of lading and title transfer agreement need to be submitted. The corresponding goods name, HS code, quantity and weight parameters must be completely consistent.

The system will automatically compare the goods flow trajectory, and no entry or exit record of China's territory will trigger price verification. For the situation where the income and expense amounts are the same, just note the flat order matchmaking attribute during filing, no additional price difference declaration to customs is required. As long as the documents form a logical closed loop, the transaction will not be determined as a false transaction.

Charlotte
CharlotteYears of service:4Customer Rating:5.0

Currency Exchange AdvisorStart a Chat

The core title document of entrepot trade is the fully negotiable ocean bill of lading. No record of any port within China's territory shall appear at the port of discharge and port of delivery on the bill of lading. The shipper on the bill of lading corresponds to the upstream seller, and the initial consignee is the intermediate party of the transaction, who will transfer the bill of lading directly to the downstream buyer via blank endorsement.

The entire goods flow trajectory occurs completely outside China's customs territory. Even if the income and expense amounts are exactly the same, as long as a full set of copies of bills of lading, screenshot of manifest trajectory query, and certificate issued by the shipping company proving that the goods do not call at any Chinese port throughout the voyage can be provided, the genuine transfer of title can be corroborated, avoiding the problem of inability to produce proof during subsequent verification.

Alexander
AlexanderYears of service:10Customer Rating:5.0

Senior Trade AdvisorStart a Chat

Entrepot trade does not fall into the scope of domestic value-added tax taxable activities, so there is no need to issue value-added tax invoices. For flat order transactions with exactly identical income and expense amounts, as long as a full set of business documents can be provided to corroborate the authenticity of the transaction, no domestic value-added tax is required, and no transfer pricing verification for anti-tax avoidance purposes will be triggered.

Make sure to keep the corresponding overseas purchase and sales agreements and goods transportation documents, which can be directly submitted during subsequent tax correspondence verification to prove that the entire transaction occurs outside China, does not belong to domestic taxable business, no input tax transfer-out or supplementary tax payment is required, and no additional tax cost will be incurred.

David
DavidYears of service:3Customer Rating:5.0

Business Development AdvisorStart a Chat

By 2026, the Cross-border Interbank Payment System (CIPS) has realized trajectory traceability of all cross-border transactions. For entrepot trade transactions with exactly identical income and expense amounts, when making international revenue and expenditure declaration, select transaction code 123010 (entrepot trade), and note "entrepot flat order, no profit" in the postscript.

Do not randomly select other irrelevant transaction codes, to avoid being marked as suspicious capital flow by the system. The records of collection and payment via offshore accounts must be completely consistent with the payment time specified in the transaction contract, and the interval shall not exceed 7 working days, which can greatly reduce the probability of being alerted by the system.

Ella
EllaYears of service:10Customer Rating:5.0

Senior Financial AdvisorStart a Chat

For flat order entrepot transactions, clauses stipulating zero spread matchmaking shall be clearly marked in the two purchase and sales contracts, and a tripartite title transfer agreement shall be additionally signed, clarifying that the goods are directly delivered from the upstream seller to the downstream buyer, and the intermediate matchmaking party only acts as a platform party without actual contact with the goods.

The signing date of all transaction documents shall conform to the reasonable timeline of goods flow, avoiding logical loopholes such as the contract signing date being later than the bill of lading issuance date. Once transaction disputes arise in the future, the full set of signed documents can be used as effective legal proof.

Sophia
SophiaYears of service:7Customer Rating:5.0

Senior Customs AdvisorStart a Chat

Since the goods of entrepot trade do not enter China's customs territory throughout the whole process, no on-site inspection process at any port will be triggered, and there is no need to prepare domestic customs clearance documents such as customs declaration forms and power of attorney for customs declaration. As long as a full set of supporting documents for overseas goods flow can be provided, even if the customs launches a special spot check on entrepot trade subsequently, the documents can be submitted quickly for verification, no additional costs such as port demurrage and goods detention will be incurred, and the normal goods pick-up time of downstream customers will not be delayed.

Daniel
DanielYears of service:8Customer Rating:5.0

Legal AdvisorStart a Chat

The goods of entrepot trade circulate entirely outside China throughout the process, so the packaging requirements only need to fully match the transportation standards from the port of departure to the port of destination, and do not need to comply with the import goods packaging specifications of China's ports. For example, no IPPC mark is required on wooden packaging, and the corresponding MSDS document only needs to meet the regulatory requirements of the port of departure and the port of destination, no additional domestic dangerous goods classification appraisal is required, which can reduce unnecessary compliance cost expenditure and shorten the overall transportation preparation cycle.

Emily
EmilyYears of service:3Customer Rating:5.0

Client Success AdvisorStart a Chat

Entrepot trade does not belong to the actual export customs declaration scenario, and the export tax rebate policy is not applicable, so there is no need to go through the procedure of export foreign exchange verification and cancellation. For flat order transactions with exactly identical income and expense amounts, as long as the four flows (contract flow, title flow, capital flow and information flow) of the documents are completely matched, no tax correspondence verification alert will be triggered.

There is no need to prepare domestic export corresponding filing documents, and only need to keep the full set of overseas transaction documents for archiving and future reference, which will not affect the tax rebate declaration qualification of the enterprise's regular export business at all.

Note: We respect all users' opinions and contributions. However, comments and answers reflect the views of their respective authors only.